Americans See Political Rhetoric Fueling Violence – And They’re Reacting

A series of polls conducted after Charlie Kirk’s assassination reveal a sobering truth. Most Americans now believe that the way our leaders and pundits discuss politics is not only divisive but also genuinely dangerous.

A Rasmussen Reports survey conducted in mid-September after Charlie Kirk’s assassination found that 85% of likely voters expect increased political violence in the upcoming months, with nearly half saying it is “very likely.” The poll also showed a significant partisan divide over causes, with 50% of Republicans, 41% of Democrats, and 48% of independents blaming heated political rhetoric, while 39% of Democrats instead cite firearm availability.

Ninety percent (90%) of voters overall expressed concern about political violence, with 69% being “very concerned.” Importantly, a strong majority across party lines, 61% of Republicans, 53% of Democrats, and 60% of independents, also agreed with President Donald Trump’s warning that demonizing political opponents can have tragic consequences.

A Reuters/Ipsos poll conducted September 12-14 found that 63% of U.S. adults said political rhetoric has contributed “a lot” to encouraging violence, while another 31% said it has contributed “a little.” Only 5% dismissed the link entirely. 

Notably, the concern cuts across partisan lines: 70% of Democrats, 63% of Republicans, and 61% of independents agree that the tone of our discourse fuels real-world violence.

A YouGov survey conducted on September 10 reached similar conclusions: 59% of adults said political violence is a “very big problem,” including 58% of Democrats and 67% of Republicans. The perception is especially strong among older Americans, with 69% of seniors viewing political violence as a very big problem, compared to just half of adults under 30.

A Morning Consult poll released the same week revealed that an astonishing 86% of Americans are concerned about political violence. About one-third of respondents blame both sides equally, but 16% say the left bears significantly more responsibility, while 17% point to the right.

Taken together, these polls reveal a nearly universal concern: Americans of all political backgrounds believe politics has become unsafe, rhetoric has turned toxic, and violence poses a real threat in everyday life.

But surveys only measure opinions in theory. In real life, the response from everyday, non-politically engaged Americans is even more telling.

Millions of Americans who rarely look past football scores and TikTok posts have been shocked into political awareness by two horrifying images in the past week: first, the brutal stabbing of a young woman by a career criminal who had been repeatedly released; second, the shocking murder of Charlie Kirk while addressing students.

For these citizens, whom we can call “normies,” people who do not live on Twitter or attend rallies, the message is visceral. Politics now directly threatens their physical safety.

Many watched footage of Kirk’s assassination not as a political event but as a human tragedy, imagining their own spouse or child in his place. Their grief turned to anger when they opened Instagram or Facebook and saw some local voices including nurses, teachers, and bureaucrats not condemning the act but celebrating it.

The polls confirm what this gut feeling indicates, that Americans no longer see political violence as a distant threat. They perceive it as happening now and often driven by those who should condemn it.

Here lies the political peril for Democrats. Even if only a minority of progressives openly celebrate political killings, many Americans view the broader left as unwilling to curb its extremes. Every time a university administrator defends a violent criminal in the name of “equity,” or a social media influencer justifies attacks on conservatives, the perception that the left is complicit grows.

The Morning Consult survey’s split on blame shows that roughly equal numbers of respondents blame both the left and the right. But the story that “Democratic leaders have enabled chaos” strongly appeals to newly radicalized citizens who seek order, safety, and security for their families.

The polling shows that political violence is no longer a niche issue. Instead it has become mainstream. Nearly nine out of ten Americans are concerned about it. Large majorities across parties agree that rhetoric is fueling the problem. And millions of voters who once felt indifferent are now responding by shifting their support toward those who promise to restore order.

Perhaps this marks the beginning of something new. Church attendance surged last weekend following Charlie Kirk’s assassination. Charlie’s organization, Turning Point USA, received more than 37,000 inquiries from people wanting to start new campus chapters. Is this a genuine revival or just a temporary reaction? Only time will tell.

For Democrats, this should be a wake-up call. Merely condemning violence in broad terms isn’t enough. Voters expect accountability from their own ranks, along with a willingness to censure activists, academics, and local officials who excuse or celebrate bloodshed. Without that, Americans will continue to believe that the left is responsible for increasing instability and violence.

For Republicans, the opportunity is clear – connect with the “normies” who are angry, scared, and suddenly involved in politics. Focus on safety, stability, and community values instead of abstract faculty lounge ideas and principles.

The message from these polls is clear. Americans feel the rhetoric has gone too far, the violence is real, and they are ready to take political action to protect themselves. The only question is which party will recognize how serious this moment is and which one will ignore it.

Brian C. Joondeph, M.D., is a physician and writer.

Follow me on Twitter @retinaldoctor

Substack Dr. Brian’s Substack

Truth Social @BrianJoondeph

LinkedIn @Brian Joondeph

Email brianjoondeph@gmail.com